| HOME / ABOUT / ARCHIVE / SNIPPETS ARCHIVE / AUDIO / AUDIO ARCHIVE / CONTACT | ||
![]() |
||
|
Scene above: Constitution Island, where Revolutionary War forts still exist, as photographed from Trophy Point, United States Military Academy, West Point, New York Please note that you can leave a comment on any of our posts at our Facebook page. Subscribers can also comment at length at our Angel's Corner Forum.
I appeared on Silvio Canto Jr.'s talk show from Dallas yesterday, discussing the biological problems of Osama bin Laden. It's here.
MAY 3, 2011 ABOUT TIME – AT 11:55 P.M. ET: President Obama has reportedly invited former President George W. Bush to join him at Ground Zero in New York on Thursday. However, Mr. Bush has declined the invitation. It's also reported that Nancy Pelosi has telephoned former President Bush to thank him for his role in the ultimate elimination of Osama bin Laden. Clearly, Democrats have been stung by the criticism, correct, that they lacked class in the way Mr. Bush's role was downplayed in Mr. Obama's initial announcement of the successful bin Laden raid. As for Bush declining Obama's invitation, no reason was given. There could be any number of reasons, including the possible feeling that was being used. Or, perhaps, he felt the focus should be on the current president. It is gratifying to know, though, that at least some people are starting to recognize George Bush's contribution. May 3, 2011 Permalink
BOTCHING IT – AT 9:03 P.M. ET: It was to be expected that conspiracy theorists and America haters would come out of the woodwork after bin Laden's death, but did we have to help them so much? It's now been acknowledged that some of the key statements made by administration members describing the killing of bin Laden were wrong. He did not have a gun, the woman he used as a shield was not his wife, and she was not killed. The man who misled us was John Brennan, Mr. Obama's chief counterterrorism adviser. In that position, Brennan should be most sensitive to the impact of inaccurate statements that later have to be withdrawn. They lead to an explosion of conspiracy theories and accusations. Brennan has made inaccurate statements before in his job, and should now be eased out of the administration. He just doesn't cut it. The administration has botched the aftermath of the brilliantly conducted raid that got bin Laden. Contradictory statements, and a curious lack of understanding that absolute proof had to be provided have now set off a wave of skepticism. True, no matter what we did there would be doubt in some quarters, especially in the Mideast, where conspiracy theories are often a substitute for thought. But again, we made matters worse. It was not necessary for bin Laden to be dumped into the ocean within 24 hours of death. There is a limit to how much "sensitivity" we had to show. It would have been better to keep the body for a few days to provide absolute proof of death. Identification by family members might have been done. The body could have been examined by a neutral authority from say, the World Health Organization or the Red Cross. This part of the planning was not good. Now there is controversy over whether the death photos of bin Laden should be released. I have no answer. On the one hand, they could provide proof to some. On the other hand, release of the pictures will immediate provoke cries of "Photoshopped." I suspect that some photos will have to be released, and that other evidence will have to be provided. Apparently, there are very sophisticated DNA tests that can be conducted, with samples we already have, that should settle the matter, but of course people can claim they were faked. We will never satisfy everyone, but we did very little to satisfy even mild skeptics. I have no doubt whatever that bin Laden was killed in that raid. What conspiracy theorists never tell you is that the kind of conspiracies they dream up would normally require a cast of hundreds or thousands, none of whom ever leak a word. But we simply could have done better in this case. I hope some hard evidence remains that the president can present to the world. May 3, 2011 Permalink MORE OF THE USUAL SUSPECTS – AT 7:31 P.M. ET: Warlike words in the city of peace from a representative of the "religion of peace." Another reminder from the real world – not the world of political correctness – of what we're up against:
Great wisdom, deeply thought out. We must understand other cultures, mustn't we?
COMMENT: Now maybe President Obama will learn what it's like to deal with this kind of irrationality, as President Bush learned. We assume it will have an impact. May 3, 2011 Permalink THE POLITICS OF IT – AT 9:44 A.M. ET: Already, and understandably, we are seeing some members of the punditry examine the political implications of the bin Laden action for President Obama. The reactions range all the way from the moronic - one of the "ladies" of "The View" suggested that we just cancel the 2012 election because Obama has it – to dubious assertions that this will have no effect at all. It will have some effect, if only the line, "He got bin Laden." The line will have some impact in strengthening Obama's sometimes dubious national-security credentials. Beyond that, it is difficult to know how many votes, if any, this episode will change. Some have cited history. It is true that George H.W. Bush had enormous approval ratings after the first Gulf War, and went on to lose the 1992 presidential election. But Bush 41 had an anemic personality and the first Gulf War, fought to "liberate" Kuwait, didn't draw the passions that bin Laden did. A more appropriate comparison is probably the 1942 midterm elections, occurring only 11 months after Pearl Harbor. The country was involved in the war effort, fighting desperately both the Japanese in the Pacific and, by the time of the election, the Nazis in North Africa. Under President Roosevelt's leadership, we had already pulled off the Doolittle raid on Tokyo and a spectacular naval victory at Midway. And yet, Roosevelt took a beating in the 1942 midterm elections. The Democrats lost 45 House seats and retained only a slender majority, even losing the popular vote. The new House, sworn in at the start of 1943, had 222 Democrats and 209 Republicans. As usual, only a third of the Senate was up, but, there too, the president suffered losses. The Democrats lost eight seats, but still retained a sizable advantage in the new Congress, with 58 Senate seats to the GOP's 37, with one Progressive. (That adds up to 96. Please note that Alaska and Hawaii had not yet become states.) Roosevelt's majorities eroded because of grumbling over the war and loss of support in some ethnic communities. America was never quite as united as some sugar-coated histories tell us. It never is, any more than Britain was completely united. Britain threw Churchill out in 1945, before the war even ended. Roosevelt was losing popularity in part because he'd served so long. He did get reelected in 1944, but not by an overwhelming margin, considering America's dramatic path to wartime victory. No way to predict, then, how Obama will do next year. We do know that military success doesn't always translate into political victory, especially if that success occurs long before the election. May 3, 2011 Permalink
FROM WEIRD TO WEIRDER – AT 9:13 A.M. ET: If you want to see printed proof of how far gone the Iranian regime is, just consider its take on the killing of Osama bin Laden, as reflected in the party-line press:
So bin Laden was a secret ally of the United States. As Johnny Carson used to say, "I did not know that."
COMMENT: This is the kind of stuff that's fed to the Iranian people. And stuff like it is fed to many residents of the "Arab street" throughout the Mideast. This twisting of minds creates profound problems for us, but receives virtually no attention from the American media, which seems to have little interest in how public opinion is actually formed, especially in dictatorships. May 3, 2011 Permalink LET'S GET IT RIGHT, FELLAS – AT 8:50 A.M. ET: We still, as a nation, bask in the glow of bin Laden's termination, but already the conspiracy theorists and borderline mental cases are at work, casting doubt, demanding super-proof and raising the kinds of questions previously reserved for George W. Bush. Unfortunately, some information botches aren't helping matters. From The Politico:
COMMENT: If they don't get their stories straight, conspiracy theories will grow. All we need is stories in the Muslim world claiming that bin Laden was "murdered" in cold blood, despite putting up no resistance. And the hard left waits in the wings, ready to pounce with its own "narrative." Consummate wackjob Cindy Sheehan is already out with a claim that bin Laden isn't dead. The White House has got to produce a clean story, and I'm afraid pictures of the dead bin Laden may have to be released. Bin laden's physical size was unique in the Arab world – he was a very tall man in a society of shorter men, and tha fact alone is compelling. But let's get all the evidence out to silence the unbelievers, who see profits and books ahead. May 3, 2011 Permalink VICTORY UP NORTH – AT 8:28 A.M. ET: Americans, to put it mildly, do not follow Canadian politics very closely. But Canada is one of our closest allies, shares our longest border, and is our largest trading partner. It also has, today, a remarkably pro-American prime minister in Steve Harper. Canada just held a national election and Harper's conservatives won a clean majority in Parliament, meaning he can govern without forming a coalition. This is rare in a country that tends to tilt left, but Harper has done it, and it's good news for the Yanks:
Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful. It's the western Canadian provinces that provide the conservative base in Canada, but we've even seen conservative strides in Toronto, a liberal city, just as we saw conservative strides under Rudy Giuliani in New York. Issues like high crime drive even traditionally liberal voters to the right. The news is not all good. The New Democrats, who made great strides, are a typical European leftist party with an aloof attitude toward the United States. Fortunately, they're in a minority and not a current threat. It will be up to Steve Harper to make short work of them and expose them for what they are, a throwback to the 1960s. May 3, 2011 Permalink
MAY 2, 2011 SECURITY REDUCED? – AT 9:53 P.M. ET: It seemed to me that the security at Grand Central Station, a major target, was far less when I left for home than when I arrived. I have no explanation for this. New York is going through a severe budget crunch, and maybe that was a factor. It's still all bin Laden all the time. The ultimate reality show. President Obama is coming to Ground Zero later this week, his visit symbolizing the end of the bin Laden saga. It's a good political stroke as well. He'll be photographed with cops, firemen and other emergency personnel, and once again we will see Obama the "moderate" presented to the electorate. One of the most inspiring things today was to see the number of college students out demonstrating on behalf of America. Even the most elite of college newspapers, the Harvard Crimson and the Columbia Spectator, featured bin Laden's end on their front pages, and showed photos of students cheering.
It has been reported that professors watching the demonstrations were treated for shock and given the last rites of the Young Socialists Club. May 2, 2011 Permalink
NEW YORK ON ALERT – AT 5:46 P.M. ET: I'm writing this from a park bench just outside Central Park, on Fifth Avenue. I'm going to hear a private talk in a few minutes on some of the creative shenanigans on Wall Street. I left Grand Central Station a short time ago and, yes, the security was much heavier than usual. I saw knots of police officers with bomb-sniffing dogs, and I witnessed one traveler pulled over to have his bags inspected. I did not hear any ACLU members shouting "Fascism!" but that may happen on the way back. Some of the nursery schools haven't let out yet. Obviously, security like that cannot stop a suicide bomber, but it can deter a terrorist who'd like to see tomorrow. I was glad to see the cops, who looked pretty serious about their work. New Yorkers tend to take these things in stride. No one seemed particularly bothered. I have what I call the "48-hour rule." It holds that it takes about 48 hours after a major news event for the left to get reorganized and start spouting its line. We're seeing some early signs. We'll see if the rule holds. May 2, 2011 Permalink
THE USUAL SUSPECTS – AT 10:35 A.M. ET: While most sane people are shedding no tears over the death of Osama bin Laden, there are those who are indeed all choked up. Included in this exclusive club are the leaders of Hamas, which controls Gaza, and has just entered into a unity agreement with the Palestinian Authority, which controls the West Bank. From Reuters:
COMMENT: The sound you hear is Jimmy Carter and like-minded Hamas sympathizers rushing to explain away that statement. We should remember what Haniyeh said the next time we're informed that Hamas is really a swell group of guys who are misunderstood in the West. No misunderstanding those words. May 2, 2011 Permalink THE HISTORIC PRECEDENT – AT 10:02 A.M. ET: The erasure of Osama bin Laden marks the second time in the lifetime of many of us that the United States has mounted a spectacular operation to kill someone who masterminded a military attack on the United States. On April 18, 1943, the United States launched Operation Vengeance to kill Japanese Admiral Isoroku Yamamoto, who'd planned the attack on Pearl Harbor in 1941. The operation was based on intelligence reports that told us of Yamamoto's travel plans in the Solomon Islands, in the southwest Pacific. A flight of Army Air Force Lockheed P-38 Lightning twin-engine fighters was sent out, and intercepted Yamamoto's plane in exactly the spot and at exactly the time the intelligence reports predicted. Yamamoto's aircraft crashed on the island of Bougainville, later taken by American troops. Yamamoto's death had a devastating impact on the morale of the Japanese Navy, equivalent, one distinguished naval historian has written, to losing a major battle. The crash site of Yamamoto's plane is preserved to this day, and has become a tourist attraction. May 2, 2011 Permalink
LIVE TWITTERING THE BIN LADEN OP – AT 8:56 A.M. ET: This story is going viral. A Pakistani guy live Twittered the bin Laden operation without realizing what it was. From London's Telegraph:
COMMENT: Watch this guy become a 15-minutes-of-fame American TV star. May 2, 2011 Permalink
MYSTERY – AT 8:27 A.M. ET: There will be many mysteries to come out of the bin Laden operation, but one that is featuring prominently this morning involves the question of how much Pakistan actually knew about bin Laden's whereabouts, and whether elements within the Pakistan government were actually helping him. From the L.A. Times:
Right near the training center? I wonder how many cadets were brought in for inspiration.
COMMENT: Pakistan is insisting this morning that the bin Laden operation was an entirely U.S. affair. Obviously, the Pakistan government fears retaliation from the huge number of fanatics residing in the country should they suspect that their own country was involved in killing the Islamist matinee idol. May 2, 2011 Permalink DETAILS EMERGE – AT 8:05 A.M. ET: We don't have all the details on the American operation that killed bin Laden, but some facts are known. It is widely reported that Navy SEALS were involved. From CNN:
And...
And...
I wonder if Hollywood will now make a movie, or will the "artists" out there consider the theme too pro-American? I think all bets are off. We also await the first book claiming that bin Laden is alive and playing poker with Elvis. May 2, 2011 Permalink
BIN LADEN APPARENTLY BURIED AT SEA – AT 7:38 A.M. ET: As Staples says, "That was easy." News reports say that Osama bin Laden, biologically impacted yesterday by an American team, has been buried at sea. This is entirely logical, and it's not the first time the oceans have been used to swallow up a demon. When Israel executed Adolph Eichmann, the organizer of the Holocaust, he was cremated and his ashes scattered at sea. The purpose: A burial site on land can become a shrine. A number of leaders, including Angela Merkel of Germany and David Cameron of Britain, have praised the American operation that led to bin Laden's final chapter. But it is reported that Al Qaeda websites, and those of fellow travelers, are filled with outrage and anguish. Thus, American officials have alerted U.S. embassies around the world to take special precautions. Those precautions will extend to the United States itself. Retaliatory attacks are expected. From WaPo:
Americans are reacting with understandable glee, and with a sense that justice has been done. However, we have yet to hear from Code Pink or the ACLU. May 2, 2011 Permalink
|
"What you see is news. What you know is background. What you feel is opinion."
"Councils of war breed timidity and defeatism." THE ANGEL'S CORNER Part I of The Angel's Corner will be sent late Wednesday night. Part II will be sent over the weekend.
SUBSCRIPTIONS Subscriptions to URGENT AGENDA are voluntary. Why subscribe to something you're getting free? To help guarantee that you'll continue to get it at all, and to get The Angel's Corner, which we now offer to subscribers and donators. Subscriptions sustain us. Payments are through PayPal and are secure, but you do not have to sign up for a PayPal account. Credit cards are fine.
FOR A SIX-MONTH ($26)
GREAT DEAL: ONE-YEAR SUBSCRIPTION WITH ANOTHER SUBSCRIPTION SENT TO SOMEONE ELSE ($69) - PERFECT FOR A SON OR DAUGHTER AT SCHOOL. (TELL US AT service@urgentagenda.com WHERE YOU WANT THE SECOND SUBSCRIPTION SENT.) CLICK:
IF YOU DON'T WISH A SET SUBSCRIPTION, BUT PREFER TO DONATE ANY OTHER AMOUNT TO SUSTAIN URGENT AGENDA, CLICK:
POWER LINE It's a privilege for me to post periodic pieces at Power Line. To go to Power Line, click here. To link to my Power Line pieces, go here.
CONTACT: YOU CAN E-MAIL US, AS FOLLOWS: If you have wonderful things to say about this site, if it makes you a better person, please click: If you have a general comment on anything you see here, or on anything else that's topical, please click:
SIZZLING SITES Power Line
LEGAL NOTICES: If you are a legal copyright holder or a designated agent for such and you believe a post on this website falls outside the boundaries of "Fair Use" and legitimately infringes on yours or your client's copyright, we may be contacted concerning copyright matters at: Urgent Agenda Phone: 914-420-1849 In accordance with section 512 of the U.S. Copyright Act our contact information has been registered with the United States Copyright Office.
© 2011 William Katz
|
| ````` | ||